By Drew
A couple of weeks ago, Joe Queenan (full disclosure: one of my favorite writers) published a very funny, very nasty piece in The Guardian in which he attacked modern classical music. (I particularly liked one of his lines in which he describes concert-goes who "have learned to stay awake and applaud politely at compositions by Christopher Rouse and Tan Dun. But they do this only because these works tend to be short and not terribly atonal; because they know this is the last time in their lives they'll have to listen to them.")
Needless to say, Queenan's piece has caused something of a stir among classical music blogs. It's quite possible, dim bulbs that some of them are, that they didn't realize Queenan's role as a resident cultural curmudgeon. But the debate has been nothing if not spirited. Terry Teachout, while taking Queenan to task on his total dismissal of modern music, agrees that "I don't go in for crunch-and-thump music, nor do I care for the over-and-over-and-over-again minimalism of John Adams and Philip Glass, which puts me to sleep." (I agree with a lot of what Teachout says about the modern music he likes.) Teachout's friend Ethan Iverson, who champions "frequently fiercely dissonant and somewhat tuneless" music, disagrees. (By the way, there's some terrific writing going on from these bloggers, so don't think that the links I've chosen here are anything more than the tip of the iceberg in this discussion. And check out the writers they link to as well - you might not agree with them, as I didn't, but you'll be informed about the discussion by reading them.)
I suppose the way you feel about classical music in general will dictate your answer to this question. If you feel that it's a window to God's creation, for example, you probably tend to side more with Jay Nordlinger, who wrote that
Music critics and other such types like to say that what the public really wants is modern music — Cage, Birtwistle, Stockhausen. None of this Classical Top 40 stuff. But this is wishful thinking, of course. If you give 'em Tchaikovsky, Beethoven, and "Finlandia" — not to mention "Carmen" or "William Tell" — boy, do they come.
As is often the case, I gotta go with Jay on this. (Even though there's plenty more good stuff out there than the "top 40" that you hear on classical radio nowadays - hey program directors, you ever heard of "deep cuts"?) Yes, there are twentieth-century composers that I'm very fond of - Britten, Stravinsky, Copeland, Rorem, Barber, Menotti, even Ligetti and Webern. Now, there are a lot of critics who would complain that this music isn't "modern" enough for them (except perhaps for the last two). But, as we've written many times at this site, there is an undeniable relationship between truth and beauty, particularly the natural beauty in the tones that mirror the rhythms of the human body. (And we touched on modern music as well, as this link to our four-part roundable from last year on "Art and Politics" will attest.)
And so we are left with this question to ponder: is there, in fact, a relationship between the harshness of modern music and the harshness of our modern culture? For we have become a harsh people, in our words, our opinions, our very way of life. Some call it edgy, but others might suggest it's merely nasty. Is that a good thing? Is our culture really better off now than it was fifty years ago?
I'm just asking.
LOS ANGELES (Reuters) - Television star Kelsey Grammer, best known from "Cheers" and his sitcom "Frasier," nearly died after suffering a heart attack last month, he told U.S. showbiz news program "Entertainment Tonight." Grammer, 53, felt chest pains while paddle-boarding with his wife in Hawaii, where they have a second home, and was taken to hospital, where he was found to have suffered a heart attack.
While her Gossip Girl costar Blake Lively was across town checking out the "Dark Knight" movie premiere, Leighton Meester was busy at the Longchamp 60th Anniversary soiree.
We've all fallen in love with her thanks to the "Hogan Knows Best" reality show. And now Brooke Hogan is spreading her wings with a new show of her very own.
The long wait is finally over, as Angelina Jolie and Brad Pitt welcomed healthy baby twins into the world on Saturday night (July 12).
WASHINGTON (AFP) - Salim Ahmed Hamdan, who is to go on trial Monday after more than six years at the US "war on terror" camp at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, is a Yemeni orphan who was driver and bodyguard to Al-Qaeda leader Osama bin Laden.Born in Hadramout, Yemen, around 1970, Hamdan was captured in Afghanistan in November 2001 after five years of allegedly close service to the man behind the September 11, 2001 attacks on the United States.
Back for another day of filming at the beach, Miley Cyrus tossed on her blonde wig as she playfully shot a few more surfboard scenes in Malibu on Thursday (July 10).
She's branching off on her own Reality TV career and Brooke Hogan is all about drumming up as much publicity as possible to insure it's a success.
LOS ANGELES - Tiger Woods won three trophies at the ESPY Awards on Wednesday night, including his fifth male athlete of the year award, giving him a career-leading 21 wins in the show's 16-year history.Woods surpassed retired cyclist Lance Armstrong for most wins as male athlete. He earned his fourth consecutive ESPY for best golfer and won best championship performance for his playoff victory at the U.S. Open on a bad left knee.
She's been tantalizing American guys for almost two decades now, and it's time for Pamela Anderson to show the boys down in Australia some attention.
Still keeping mum on the name of her babydaddy, Minnie Driver was spotted out and about in Santa Monica, California yesterday picking up some takeout food.
After a rousing couple of days with her boyfriend Reggie Bush and both of their families, Kim Kardashian grabbed a little time for herself on Saturday.
They've got the world's top hair stylists on speed dial, but even Hollywood's most stylish stars suffer from the dreaded bad hair day now and then. We found them at their best -- and hair-raising worst! Here, Katherine Heigl
Please tell us this mullet-inspired chop job is for a movie role! Hopefully Jada's hair will grow out soon to our preferred look -- shiny and sleek
Only Bo Derek could be a perfect "10" in cornrows. We're glad this new mommy has traded her Dirrty 'do for Marilyn Monroe-inspired platinum blonde waves.
No wonder Posh started a blunt bob trend in Hollywood -- it suits her perfectly. In her stodgy up-do, however, she looks like she's taking her reputation as an ice queen a little too seriously
How did L.A.'s biggest party girl end up with a soccer mom haircut? Luckily, Paris soon grew her 'do into a perfectly flirty asymmetrical bob
Surrounded by friends and co-workers from her recent gig as Hans Klok's assistant, party-loving Pamela Anderson celebrated her birthday with a bash at LAX nightclub in Las Vegas on Saturday night (July 5).
Keira Knightley
Janet Jackson during the halftime show at Super Bowl XXXVIII between the New England Patriots and the Carolina Panthers at Reliant Stadium on February 1, 2004 in Houston, Texas.
Actress Lindsay Lohan attends an intimate dinner hosted by Chanel and Sienna Miller in honor of Les Exclusifs de Chanel held at Chateau Marmont on January 11, 2007 in Hollywood, California. Les Exclusifs de Chanel is a collection of rare and exclusive fragrances
Singer Fergie from Black Eyed Peas attends the VH1 - Big in '04 at the Shrine Auditorium December 1, 2004 in Los Angeles, California
Actress Bail Ling enjoys the awards show during the Outfest 2005 Awards Night on July 17, 2005 at the John Anson Ford Amphitheatre in Los Angeles, California.
After a rousing couple of days with her boyfriend Reggie Bush and both of their families, Kim Kardashian grabbed a little time for herself on Saturday.

STUDIO CITY, Calif. - "Big Brother 10" is returning to its roots. The claustrophobic CBS reality show is sealing 13 actual strangers — no ex lovers, secret twin partners or long-lost siblings this time — inside a makeshift house on a Studio City soundstage for the chance to be the last houseguest standing and take home the $500,000 grand prize.
Commanding the stage in a colorful floral patterned ensemble, Leona Lewis helped Nelson Mandela celebrate his 90th birthday during a big concert in London on Friday (June 27).
NEW YORK (Reuters) - Pop star Madonna denied having an affair with Yankee slugger Alex Rodriguez and said in a statement to People magazine on Sunday she is not planning to get divorced from her British husband Guy RitchieRumors that the London-based couple planned to split have been circulating for months, fueled most recently by reports that she had hired a lawyer to divorce film maker Ritchie.
TOYAKO, Japan - President Bush said Sunday he does not feel the need to boycott the opening ceremonies of the Beijing Olympics to state his opposition to China's human rights record. Skipping the event would be an "affront" to the Chinese people, he said. Bush spoke at a news conference with Japanese Prime Minister Yasuo Fukuda, who announced that he also plans to attend the ceremonies. Other world leaders have decided not to go as a rebuke to China's violent crackdown on anti-government protests in Tibet.
To their credit, they've lasted way longer than their critics said they would. And last night Paris Hilton and Benji Madden were out on a clubbing date looking as loving as ever.
STOCKHOLM (Reuters) - All four members of supergroup ABBA appeared together on Friday at the Swedish premiere of the film "Mamma Mia!," delighting fans with their first public showing for years. Benny Andersson, Bjorn Ulvaeus, Anni-Frid Lyngstad -- known as Frida -- and Agnetha Faltskog walked down the red carpet at a Stockholm movie theatre to the cheers of several thousand fans.
Los Angeles (E! Online) - GARDEN VARIETY: Chloë Sevigny, carrying a Donna Karan Modern Leo Tote bag while picking up flowers at a grocery store in L.A.BAND OF BROTHERS: Madonna and Guy Ritchie's sons, Rocco and David, bowling at Bowlmor Lanes in Union Square in NYC. (No, they weren't alone! A nanny and bodyguard were in tow.)
PARIS - "I cry with joy," Ingrid Betancourt said. And she did. After six years as a hostage in the Colombian jungle, the former Colombian presidential candidate and French citizen flew back to her beloved France to be embraced Friday as an icon by the country that raised her.
LOS ANGELES (AP) — Larry Harmon, who turned the character Bozo the Clown into a show business staple that delighted children for more than a half-century, died Thursday of congestive heart failure. He was 83His publicist, Jerry Digney, told The Associated Press he died at his home.




